All About All:WikiProject Stub sorting/Proposals/Archive - All About All

All About All:WikiProject Stub sorting/Proposals/Archive

This is an archive of the stub type proposals from WP:WSS.

For older discussions on this subject, see the Criteria page archive.

Note to archivers

Archive1 summary

Archived August 20th 2005

• mining-stub - not created
• fictional-character-stub - created as fict-char-stub
• bio-book-stub - created
• units-stub - not created
• google-stub - not created
• accounting-stub - created
• compu-lang-stub category change - implemented
• UK-constituency-stub - created
• Wisconsin stubs - created
• Horseracing-stub - created
• chemist-stub - created
• physicist-stub - created
• Ireland-bio-stub - created

Archive2 summary

Archived August 27th 2005

• aero-corp-stub and telecom-corp-stub - created, along with a number of other xxx-corp-stubs
• country-stub|CountryName - created before proposal
• Washington State Highway Stub - created before proposal
• California-south-geo-stub - created
• split of mythology stubs - Euro-myth-stub, Greek-myth-stub, Asia-myth-stub, Africa-myth-stub, Oceania-myth-stub and Americas-myth-stub created

Archive3 summary

Archived September 3rd 2005

• Subdivision of food-stub - {{drink-stub}}, {{beer-stub}}, {{wine-stub}}, {{food-utensil-stub}}, {{fruit-stub}}, {{vegetable-stub}} created.
• anthropology-stub - not created
• Country category standardization
• Primitive-Technology-stub - not created
• {{rpg-stub}} - created
• {{Honduras-geo-stub}} - created
• US-edu-stub and UK-edu-stub - created as {{US-school-stub}} and {{UK-school-stub}}
• Battlestar Galactica - not created
• Society - not created
• More country bios - not created
• More geo-stubs - {{pennsylvania-geo-stub}}, {{texas-geo-stub}}, {{michigan-geo-stub}}, {{guatemala-geo-stub}}, and {{nigeria-geo-stub}} created
• Australian and Canadian School Stubs - created as {{Australia-school-stub}} and {{Canada-school-stub}}
• {{cricketbio-stub}} - created
• Historical Fiction Book Stub - created as {{hist-book-stub}}
• Make firearms-stub a subcat of weapon-stub - done
• Northern Ireland stub - created as {{NI-stub}}

Archive4 summary

Archived September 20th 2005

• subdivision of broadcasting-stub - continued discussion
• first split of English geo-stubs - nine county-geo-stubs created
  • discussion on dynamic stubs and redirects
  • {{}} - created, later deleted
• {{Diving-stub}} - not created
• Reorganisation of US highway stubs - {{UShighway-stub}} created
• {{}} - not created
• subdivision of {{rail-stub}} - separate France, Netherlands, India, Canada, Japan rail-stubs created
• {{}} - not created
• split of {{invertebrate-stub}} - {{insect-stub}}, {{butterfly-stub}}, {{mollusc-stub}} and {{crustacean-stub}} created
• {{}} - not created
• {{med-corp-stub}} - created
• {{Astronaut-stub}} - created
• {{Georgia-geo-stub}} and {{GeorgiaUS-geo-stub}} - created
• {{Maldives-geo-stub}} - created
• {{Neuroscience-stub}} - created
• {{card-game-stub}} - created
• {{}} - not created

Discussions:

• {{Animation-stub}} and {{Disney-stub}}
• {{}} and multi-geo-stubbing
• New hierarchy for education stubs - created
• {{}} - not created

Archive5 summary

Archived: September 30th 2005

• {{}} - no stub type created - unable to reach consensus on name or scope
• Rail stubs
  • {{}} not created
  • {{US-rail-stub}} created
  • {{UK-rail-stub}} proposed during discussion and created
• Religion stubs
  • New sect stubs discussed but not created
  • {{church-stub}} created
• Food stubs
  • {{restaurant-stub}} discussed, found to exist, and formally adopted
  • {{cheese-stub}} created
  • Changing Cat:Food and drink stubs to be a stubless parent category with {{food-stub}} pointing to new Cat:Food stubs discussed but not adopted
• {{Oz-stub}} created
• {{NewHampshire-stub}} not created
• {{Gaelic-sport-stub}} created
• {{battle-stub}} created
• {{}} not created
• {{fashion-bio-stub}} created
• {{photographer-stub}} created
• {{radio-bio-stub}} created
• Earth Scientist stubs
  • {{geoscience-bio-stub}} created
    • {{climate-bio-stub}} created
    • {{geologist-stub}} created
• {{relativity-stub}} created
• {{CAsia-stub}} created
• {{orchid-stub}} created

Archive6 summary

Archived: October 3rd 2005

• {{jazz-stub}} created
• More Geo stubs
  • {{Vietnam-geo-stub}} created
  • {{Saskatchewan-geo-stub}} created
  • {{Gloucestershire-geo-stub}} {{Merseyside-geo-stub}}, {{Shropshire-geo-stub}} {{Sussex-geo-stub}} created
  • {{Massachusetts-geo-stub}} {{Virginia-geo-stub}}, {{WestVirginia-geo-stub}} created
• {{France-politician-stub}}, {{NZ-politician-stub}} created
• {{polymer-stub}} created
• History stubs
  • {{historian-stub}} created
  • {{Asia-hist-stub}}, {{MEast-hist-stub}} created
  • {{}}, {{}}, {{}} not created
• Haiti stubs
  • {{Haiti-stub}} created
  • {{}}, {{}} not created
• {{US-mil-stub}} created
• {{}} not created
• {{Canada-writer-stub}}, {{France-writer-stub}} created
• {{Netherlands-stub}} created
• {{Croatia-bio-stub}} created
• Math stubs
  • {{algebra-stub}}, {{combin-stub}}, {{mathanalysis-stub}}, ((tl|mathlogic-stub}} created
  • {{}} not created
• {{philosopher-stub}} created
• {{crime-bio-stub}} created
• {{poli-bio-stub}} created
• {{MEast-bio-stub}} created
• {{Israel-bio-stub}} created
• Latin American bio stubs
  • {{}} not created
  • {{Caribbean-bio-stub}}, {{CentralAm-bio-stub}}, {{SouthAm-bio-stub}} created

Archive7 summary

Archived: October 10th 2005

• More Geo stubs
  • {{Berkshire-geo-stub}}, {{Buckinghamshire-geo-stub}}, {{Cumbria-geo-stub}}, {{Devon-geo-stub}}, {{Hampshire-geo-stub}}, {{Kent-geo-stub}}, {{Norfolk-geo-stub}}, {{Wiltshire-geo-stub}}, {{Lancashire-geo-stub}}, {{Manchester-geo-stub}}, {{Leicestershire-geo-stub}} created
  • {{Kenya-geo-stub}}, {{Trinidad-geo-stub}} created
  • {{SouthDakota-geo-stub}} created
  • {{WesternAustralia-geo-stub}}, {{NewSouthWales-geo-stub}}, {{Queensland-geo-stub}}, {{Victoria-geo-stub}} created
• {{}} not created
• {{}} not created
• {{}} deleted
• Split of {{Writer-stub}}
  • {{Africa-writer-stub}}, {{MEast-writer-stub}}, {{SAsia-writer-stub}}, {{Euro-writer-stub}}, {{Australia-writer-stub}}, {{Italy-writer-stub}}, {{China-writer-stub}}, {{Japan-writer-stub}}, {{Germany-writer-stub}}, {{Spain-writer-stub}} all created
• {{Radio-bio-stub}} created
• {{Ancient-Rome-bio-stub}} created
• {{}} not created
• {{Fashion-bio-stub}} created
• Discussions
  • US state-specific bio-stubs
  • Cat:Foo stubs vs Cat:Foo-related stubs
  • Reorganisation of People stubs subcategories
  • Realignment of border between West and Central Africa

Archive8 summary

Archived: October 21st 2005

• Split of {{Film-stub}}
  • {{Comedy-film-stub}}, {{Drama-film-stub}} (created)
  • {{}}, {{}}, {{}}, {{}} (not created)
• (not created)
• {{California-politician-stub}} (created)
• {{Canada-road-stub}} (created)
• {{Massachusetts-State-Highway-Stub}}, {{Maryland-State-Highway-Stub}}, {{Michigan-State-Highway-Stub}}, {{Nevada-State-Highway-Stub}}, {{NewHampshire-State-Highway-Stub}}, {{Missouri-State-Highway-Stub}} (all created)
• {{}} (not created)
• {{stockexchange-stub}} (created)
• split of footyclub-stub
  • {{Africa-footyclub-stub}}, {{US-footyclub-stub}}, {{SouthAm-footyclub-stub}}, {{Euro-footyclub-stub}} (all created)
• {{UK-retail-stub}} (created)
• CVG stubs
  • {{cvg-corp-stub}},{{simulation-cvg-stub}}, {{platform-cvg-stub}}, {{rpg-cvg-stub}}, {{sports-cvg-stub}}, {{shooter-cvg-stub}}, {{strategy-cvg-stub}}, {{adventure-cvg-stub}} (all created)
  • {{}}, {{}} (not created)
• Discussions
  • Broadcast & TV-related stubs
  • CVG stubs (creations listed above)
  • "What is a stub?"
  • Split of sportbio-stub

Archive9 summary

Archived: October 23rd 2005

• {{SAsia-stub}} created
• {{linguist-stub}} created
• Cat:Belgian people stubs created for existing {{Belgium-bio-stub}}
• {{athletics-stub}} created
• Sub types of {{writer-stub}}
  • {{}} and {{}} not created
• {{child-lit-stub}} created
• Sub types of {{struct-stub}}
  • {{}} not created
  • {{India-struct-stub}} created
• {{service-corp-stub}} created
• {{entertainer-stub}} created
• Sub types of {{actor-stub}} and {{US-actor-stub}}
  • {{Japan-actor-stub}} and {{voice-actor-stub}} created
  • {{US-film-actor-stub}}, {{US-theat-actor-stub}}, {{US-tv-actor-stub}}, and {{voice-actor-stub}} created
• {{story-stub}} created
• More actor stub sub types proposed but not created
• {{reli-struct-stub}} created
• Sub types of {{lang-stub}}
  • {{writingsystem-stub}}, {{conlang-stub}}, and {{pidgincreole-lang-stub}} created
• Africa Union stub not created
• {{Ethiopia-stub}} created
• {{Missouri-geo-stub}} created
• Canadian highway stub proposed, proposer pointed towards existing {{Canada-road-stub}}

Archive10 summary

Archived: October 23rd 2005

• {{Canada-mil-stub}} created
• {{archaeologist-stub}}
• Split of {{Japan-geo-stub}}
  • 37 prefecture level geo stub sub types created, 10 more identified as potential future stub types but not created due to lack of stubs
• {{California-stub}} created as replacement for {{Calif-stub}}
• New sub types of {{mil-stub}}
  • {{Russia-mil-stub}}, {{mil-vehicle-stub}}, and {{mil-aviation-stub}} created
  • {{}} not created
• Grutness' October geo-stubs - all created
  • {{Ghana-geo-stub}} and {{Sudan-geo-stub}}
  • {{Minnesota-geo-stub}}
  • {{Tasmania-geo-stub}} and {{SouthAustralia-geo-stub}}
  • {{NovaScotia-geo-stub}}
  • {{Cambridgeshire-geo-stub}}, {{Essex-geo-stub}}, and {{Derbyshire-geo-stub}}
• Road stubs - discussion of archiving of old proposals, not a proposal
• {{Euro-stub}} and {{Asia-stub}} created
• Sky television stub not created
• {{Portugal-bio-stub}}
• New sub types of {{sportbio-stub}}
  • {{athleticsbio-stub}}, {{boxingbio-stub}}, {{badmintonbio-stub}}, {{rugbybio-stub}}, and {{skatingbio-stub}} created
• {{Norway-politician-stub}} created
• {{Portugal-explorer-stub}} created
• {{material-stub}} created
• {{death-stub}} created
• Uncyclopedia Parallel/Parody Article stub not created